” ‘How did you go bankrupt?’ Bill asked. ‘Two ways,’ Mike said. ‘Gradually and then suddenly.’ “ Ernest Hemingway, The Sun Also Rises, 1926.
And so it was in 2001 that we inched towards recession month by month until the events of 11th September. Media giants who had previously boasted that their size and diversity of interests made them ‘recession-proof’ lost millions practically overnight and job losses and cost-cutting measures were not enough to redress the balance sheets.
January
In a move that seems now somewhat fanciful and outdated, Associated Newspapers launched its second attempt at a women’s web offering on 6 January. Initially meant as a relaunch of charlottestreet.com, femail.co.uk emerged with barely a trace of its forebear and was billed as a “2nd generation women’s web site”. Femail survived the year, many didn’t. Whilst Associated was taking the web by storm, Future Publishing was already on its second profits warning, having already revised its expectations for year end results once in November 2000. ‘Softness’ in the computer games market and the absence of a seasonal uplift was blamed for the decline in profits.
Elsewhere the Radio Authority announced a modernisation of its advertising rules, four websites owned by Express Newspapers closed after the company failed to find a buyer for them and the IPA said that fears of recession had been exaggerated whilst the brokers downgraded media shares and warned of a tough six months ahead.
February
German media group Bertelsmann acquired a controlling stake in European broadcaster RTL, Liberty Media was said to be interested in buying Vivendi’s stake in BSkyB and Rupert Murdoch was thought to be close to agreeing a deal to buy DirecTV. These companies and their respective take-overs and mergers remained in the news all year as greater consolidation of the markets became the driving force within media companies in 2001.
WPP saw record profits in February as pre-tax profits for 2000 increased by 43% on the previous year. SMG also reported record profits and Anglo-Dutch publishing group Reed Elsevier turned in better-than-expected yearly results. UBM turned in an 11.4% rise in headline profit to £342.4 million for 2000 but the brokers were sceptical.
March
Carlton Communications chairman Michael Green described the UK television advertising market as ‘currently subdued’ in comparison with last year at the company’s AGM, with ITV’s revenue in the first three months down 5%. The situation would improve though, he said, with an upturn in Q4. Pearson posted pre-tax profits of £333 million for the year to 31 December 2000, 17% lower than the £402 million of last year, following an investment of £196 million in the internet.
Cordiant Communications turned in strong financial results which showed record net new business wins worth £750 million in 2000. Aegis were also confident for 2001 as its profits rose by 21% in 2000. Trinity Mirror announced better than expected pre-tax profit growth of 12.2% to £196 million whilst Future Network continued to suffer following a ‘bruising year’ in 2000.
April
The outlook started to look a little less rosy in April. Zenith, the first of many, downgraded its global advertising forecasts, predicting that in 2001 the ad market would decline for the first time since 1991. Pearson cut 40 jobs at its online division which includes FT.com, Q2 revenues at ITV were forecast to show a significant decline and Q1 results from WPP were disappointing.
NTL was rumoured to be in talks with AOL Time Warner regarding a distribution partnership and ‘Internet and ebusiness solutions company’ Bright Station began the descent into unprofitability which eventually led to a refinanced company rebranding as Smartlogik.
May
United Business Media cut its online investment for the current year from the planned £45 million to no more than £30 million blaming the ‘current market conditions’ for the investment cuts, notably the downturn in high-tech advertising in the US. Trinity Mirror chairman, Sir Victor Blank, told the company’s AGM that advertising growth for the first three months of the year slowed although revenues were expected to remain in line with forecasts made in March.
Revenues at BSkyB remained buoyant and the company announced that analogue signals would be switched off in the summer of 2001 despite still having around 150,000 customers who had not made the switch to digital. Shares in BSkyB fell as the City found the results too negative. New media costs were blamed for pushing Chrysalis into the red as Carlton and Granada decided to boost ITV’s web presence. Later in the month Carlton stock fell as the company warned on profits. GWR results were in line with expectations, Capital warned on profits and SRH was cautious as radio revenues dropped by 3.5%, against an industry average of 6.4% growth.
June
DMGT was optimistic about the future despite a slowdown at Associated Newspapers, the downturn hit jobs and profits at Cordiant and the slump at Granada continued, despite results hitting the top end of expectations. Granada warned of a ‘potential disaster’ for ITV unless the Government moved to amend media ownership regulations, UBM warned on profits and JCDecaux was forced to halve the price of its IPO.
AOL Time Warner CEO, Jerry Levin, announced that advertising revenues at the company have started to stabilise. Viacom chairman and CEO, Sumner Redstone, called his company an “advertising juggernaut” and said based on “empirical evidence” he expected the media economy to show signs of recovery in Q3/Q4 2001.
July
EMAP confirmed the sale of its USA business to US consumer publisher, Primedia, for approximately $515 million closing a ‘difficult and unhappy chapter’ in the company’s history. UBC Media turned in a set of financial results ahead of the market’s expectations. Turnover rose by 46% to £6.2 million and gross profit reached £1.7 million, up 35% on the previous year.
Shares in Tempus soared mid-month following reports that French advertising network, Havas Advertising was about to announce a takeover of Tempus for around £400 million (E658 million), thus beginning an epic saga that was to last well into November. Optimedia and Zenith were merged by their parent companies, Publicis and Cordiant respectively, creating the world’s fourth-largest media communications group, NewCo.
BSkyB turned in a strong set of year-end results, beating market expectations by some margin, operating profit increased by 88% to £160 million. Like for like revenues at GWR Group dropped by 11% in the first quarter and the company said it was not assuming any significant recovery in the advertising market until Q1 2002. UBM was forced to begin job cuts, Pearson results were poor although Trinity faired better as regionals showed greater resistance to the ad downturn.
August
Regional Independent Media reiterated that it is not interested in being split up by a consortium and that it intended to take its business public if no other suitable offers were received.
In keeping with an almost universal reappraisal of the role of the internet in media companies’ businesses, GWR Group restructured its online operations to make annual cost savings of around £1.3 million. Around 45 staff were lost in the restructure.
United Business Media posted pre-tax profits down by 48% year on year for the six months to June, impacted by the downturn in hi-tech advertising revenues at its CMP Media publishing business in the US. Things were not to improve.
Speculation began to emerge that Sir Martin Sorrell, chief executive of WPP, was poised to make a counter bid for the Tempus media buying agency just a month after reports that French group Havas Advertising was to take over the agency. This indeed came a few days later, when WPP confirmed a 555p per share offer for Tempus.
September
Havas extended its offer for Tempus a couple of times but declined to better WPP’s offer, eventually it allowed the offer to lapse leaving WPP waiting on Tempus’s financial results before deciding on whether to continue with the takeover. Tempus announced better-than-expected results and it appeared that the WPP bid would proceed as planned.
On the morning of 11 September the markets rose and the bargain hunters moved in following four days of freefall and a four-year low for the FTSE. A day later the picture was quite different, millions had been lost and stability seemed a long way off as the NYSE closed for four days in the wake of the tragedy. DMGT was one of the first companies to report that the terrorist attacks in US have had ‘an immediate impact’ on a number of its activities and was soon followed by Maiden, Cordiant and already-troubled Future.
October
After months of negotiation, WPP announced that it was seeking the consent of the Takeover Panel to invoke the material adverse change condition in order to exit from its offer for Tempus Group. Protracted negotiations ensued throughout the month.
Shares in ITV companies were hit hard late in the month as analysts at Merrill Lynch cut their forecasts for the Network’s advertising revenues. The broker pulled back 2001 growth from -14.5% to -15.5%; 2002 figures were revised from -2.0% to -2.5%.
Meanwhile, ITV Digital beat its internal subscriber growth targets for the third quarter. The business put on 82,000 customers in the quarter to September, pushing its total customer base to 1.2 million, up 36% year on year. Churn came in at 23.1%, much higher than Sky Digital’s rate of 10%.
Rupert Murdoch walked away from what many considered the ‘dream’ deal of his career – one which would have made him the greatest TV mogul ever, reaching more people in more countries than anyone else in history.
November
WPP eventually announced that it would buy Tempus following the Takeover Panel’s decision to reject its appeal to withdraw its initial offer and subsequent wranglings.
UBM, BSkyB, Wireless Group, Hollinger, Emap, IPC, News International, Capital, GWR and Granada all reported a drop in profits or cutbacks brought about by the severe ad downturn whilst a few companies managed to outperform the market; JCDecaux, SRH and Chrysalis amongst them.
In the latest consultation document on media ownership, Culture Secretary Tessa Jowell inferred that the 20% rule which currently governs cross media ownership may remain and may yet be extended to cover all media markets. Driven by the belief that “the existing media ownership rules are outdated, inconsistent and not flexible enough to respond to the rapid change we have seen in media markets”, Jowell, in a joint statement with Trade & Industry Secretary Patricia Hewitt, outlined the government’s proposals for media ownership reform.
December
Cordiant cut more jobs as profit estimates were revised down again, the message from Carlton, DMGT, RTL and Pearson was similarly gloomy. Others painted a brighter picture: in a pre-close trading statement, Johnston Press boasted profits in the ‘top range of market estimates’ and a growth in ad revenue of 1.6%, compared to to the same period 2000.
Independent News & Media said that, despite the prevalent gloomy trading conditions, it expected to deliver total 2001 revenues which are in line with 2000’s figures. Vivendi Universal sold a third of its stake in BSkyB, leaving it with a 15% share in the satellite television company and, on Christmas Eve, Pearson agreed to sell its stake in European broadcaster RTL to Bertelsmann.




