Not as easy as ABC1. Social grade explains just 7% of consumer behaviour

By

6 minutes

OMD UK released its reCLASSified report earlier this month, raising questions about the advertising industry’s reliance on ABC1 and C2DE classifications to identify valuable audiences.

Crowd at station

Charli West Avatar

Charli West is a reporter for The Media Leader and leads on coverage of audio and OOH.


Traditional social grades explain just 7% of consumer attitudes and behaviours, according to research from OMD UK, raising questions about the advertising industry’s reliance on ABC1 and C2DE classifications to identify valuable audiences.

Published last month, the study, reCLASSified, was conducted in partnership with the IPA and supported by News UK, Global and ITV. Based on a survey of more than 10,000 UK adults, it suggests occupation is becoming an increasingly unreliable predictor of how people manage their money.

While social grade explained 33% of differences in disposable income, the research found striking similarities in the financial priorities of different groups. Almost identical proportions of ABC1s and C2DEs said they preferred enjoying their money now rather than prioritising future financial security (32% and 33% respectively), while 62% of ABC1s and 61% of C2DEs said they actively limit their spending.

The research also found that 60% of homeowners with a mortgage felt financially strained, challenging assumptions that traditional indicators of affluence necessarily reflect financial comfort.

In testing, OMD’s proposed alternative framework was around 20% more accurate than ABC1 classifications at identifying consumers who said they could afford a £10,000 purchase.

Developed over two years with more than 70 representatives from across the industry, and building on OMD’s earlier The Farce of Class research, reCLASSified proposes

“The system was designed for an era when single-income households were the norm

Analysis: the role of socio-economic grouping

Traditional socio-economic grouping (SEG) was developed by the National Readership Survey (NRS, now PAMCo) in 1956. It uses the occupation of the chief income earner in the household to categorise audiences, allowing the advertising industry to trade and analyse media behaviour without asking people to disclose their earnings.

While the measure has been a cornerstone of audience planning for decades, OMD’s research questions whether this remains an accurate reflection of how modern consumers live and spend.

Laura Rowe, managing partner of marketing intelligence and inclusion at OMD UK, who led the research, told The Media Leader that the approach can create an incomplete picture of individuals within a household.

“Instinctively that feels like an uncomfortable lens,” she said. “The system was designed for an era when single-income households were the norm, yet today around 59% of UK households where all members are aged 16 or over have everyone in employment.”

She also pointed to the way occupations are classified, arguing that the system does not always reflect modern economic realities. Highly-skilled trades, such as plumbing, which can be extremely lucrative, typically fall outside the ABC1 category. Meanwhile, professions such as teaching are included, despite often earning less.

For advertisers, this means that being classified as ABC1 does not necessarily indicate someone has the disposable income or inclination to spend.

“Given how deeply SEG is entrenched in our trading behaviours, media reporting and audience profiling, we felt it was important to explore whether a more accurate alternative existed. Ultimately, better audience understanding leads to better advertising,” she added.

As Rowe put it: “SEG isn’t doing what we think it is.”

However, not everyone believes the measure should be dismissed altogether.

Tony Regan, partner at Work Research, welcomed OMD’s research and its attempt to address what he described as a long-standing limitation in an industry-wide tool. But he said that throughout his career, dating back to the late 1980s, SEG had “only ever been a foundation, not the whole solution”.

He argued that understanding attitudes, circumstances, mindsets and moods has always been necessary to connect brands with the right people, at the right time and place, rather than relying solely their social status.

Regan believes much of SEG’s continued appeal comes down to convenience. Its ability to link across an increasingly large number of datasets makes it a powerful industry tool. But the danger, he said, is that this convenience can encourage “lazy assumptions”, such as the idea that targeting ABC1 audiences is inherently more valuable than reaching C2DE consumers.

“The notion that society can be cut into ‘white collar’ and ‘blue collar’ is so obviously remnant of a long-gone industrial age,” he said.

Why SEG remains embedded in measurement

Despite the criticism, social grade continues to play an important role in the UK’s joint-industry currencies (JICs), including RAJAR and Barb.

Anne Robshaw, survey support manager at RAJAR, said the radio JIC continues to collect social grade because it remains a widely understood and used measure across UK audience measurement, media planning and the advertising industry.

It also forms part of RAJAR’s population targets and weighting framework, helping to ensure the survey reflects the profile of the UK adult population.

However, Robshaw stressed that RAJAR does not view social grade as a complete description of an individual, but as one measure among a broader set of characteristics available for analysing audiences. She added that established classifications should continue to be reviewed as society and audience behaviour evolve.

A spokesperson for Barb similarly acknowledged that socio-economic classifications is a widely used proxy for wealth and income in the TV advertising industry, but said it is increasingly outdated.

The organisation, which was involved in the research, said it was continuing to work with OMD UK and the IPA on how it could incorporate the findings into its audience measurement in future.

What does the new framework offer advertisers?

Simply targeting people based on what we think their bank account looks like is reductive.

OMD’s proposed six audience groups are designed to recognise that having the financial means to spend does not necessarily mean someone feels comfortable doing so.

While the ‘Careful Planners’ group have relatively high levels of financial freedom, they take a structured approach to spending, prioritising savings and long-term financial goals. By contrast, ‘Confident Explorers’ are more spontaneous and willing to spend on experiences and convenience.

Rowe believes this distinction is crucial for advertisers. A brand selling indulgent products or experiences, for example, might find ‘Confident Explorers’ a more relevant audience than simply targeting consumers within a particular social grade.

“When we look at people as a set of demographics, characteristics or numbers, we aren’t acknowledging the complexity behind what makes us human, different and interesting,” she said.

“Each one of us has different responsibilities, cultural influences, future plans and priorities – simply targeting people based on what we think their bank account looks like is reductive.”

The framework also recognises that people’s financial circumstances are not necessarily static. Rowe said OMD had retested the groups using its five question decision tree across entirely new surveys, finding that while their relative sizes changed, their underlying profiles remained stable.

But widespread adoption is far from guaranteed. SEG is deeply embedded in existing trading practices, datasets and measurement systems, meaning any replacement would require considerable industry collaboration.

OMD is inviting the industry to test reCLASSified against its own data and planning processes. Rowe said the agency had made its decision tree freely available so other organisations could replicate the framework in their own surveys and tools to assess whether the six audience groups could be applied consistently.

“If we want to change an industry system, everyone needs a stake in it!”

Ultimately, Rowe would like to see the industry move away from SEG altogether, particularly in trading.

“I think this work has proven it’s an inefficient and outdated way of finding people who represent real value to brands.”



Want to get involved in the discussion?

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *