Return on advertising investment (ROAS) has become one of the most familiar terms in a marketer’s measurement vocabulary. It gives CMOs an easy way to understand how much revenue a campaign generates against its media investment, helping them understand what is working and where budgets should go.
But there’s a distinction between generating a measurable return and generating additional growth. As pressure mounts on CMOs to demonstrate the commercial impact of every media pound spent, relying too heavily on ROAS can give an incomplete picture of advertising effectiveness.
The solution isn’t to move away from ROAS, but to understand the broader picture for longer-term investment decisions: how much demand media is capturing, how much it is creating and what impact it will have on future growth.
When a strong return tells an incomplete story
Performance marketing has made it easier to connect media activity with commercial outcomes. Advertisers can see which campaigns generate conversions and use that information to make faster investment decisions.
However, attribution and incrementality answer different questions. ROAS measures the revenue credited to a campaign, while incrementality examines how much additional value it created.
Consider a customer who has visited a retailer’s website several times and added a product to their basket. A retargeting ad appears shortly before they complete the purchase. The campaign receives credit for the sale, improving its reported ROAS. Yet the customer may have made the purchase regardless of the ad.
Retargeting can play an important role in converting existing demand. The difficulty arises when attributed conversions dominate performance measurement. Buying systems can then favour people who are easiest to convert, while investment in reaching potential customers becomes harder to justify. Over time, the figures may look healthy even as the campaign’s contribution to business growth weakens.
Incrementality changes the question
Incrementality testing provides a way to investigate that difference. Controlled experiments and holdout groups can help establish what would have happened without exposure to a campaign. Comparing those outcomes gives advertisers a more reliable indication of the additional sales their investment generated.
This can change how campaigns are evaluated. A campaign with a lower reported ROAS may be reaching new customers and creating additional demand. Another with a higher figure may be capturing conversions that were already likely. Without measuring incrementality, the distinction is difficult to establish.
CMOs need to understand how their results contribute to the wider growth strategy, rather than allowing one measure to dictate every investment decision.
A useful question is how much of the return would have been lost if the campaign had never run. That is a stronger test of effectiveness.
Incrementality doesn’t replace ROAS, but it gives it important context. Incremental ROAS, for example, helps advertisers understand the additional revenue generated relative to media spend. Used alongside conventional ROAS, it provides a more complete picture of short-term performance and the value media is genuinely adding.
All brands should be demanding incrementality measurement from their media partners. This would allow them to align media investment more closely with incremental sales and demonstrate marketing’s contribution to genuine business growth.
It’s a far more compelling argument in the boardroom, showing how advertising helps expand the customer base rather than simply taking credit for demand that already exists.
Attention brings media quality into the picture
The quality of the media itself also deserves consideration. An impression can be recorded without telling the marketer whether someone noticed an ad. Conversion data shows what happened afterwards, but often says little about the conditions in which the advertising was delivered.
Attention offers a useful signal between those points.
People need an opportunity to notice an ad before it can influence their thinking or behaviour. An ad appearing alongside content someone is actively engaging with has a different opportunity to make an impression from one delivered into a placement receiving little attention.
Attention can therefore help advertisers assess whether their media has the potential to support awareness or influence a purchase decision. Better audience intelligence helps identify relevant people across the open web, while attention signals can inform decisions about the placements most likely to engage them.
Used alongside conversion data and incrementality testing, it gives a more complete view of campaign effectiveness.
Growth requires a longer-term view
The longer-term risk in allowing immediate returns to dominate media decisions is the lack of focus on brand equity — something that develops through repeated exposure and experiences over time. The influence may be seen in future preferences or purchase decisions, rather than in a conversion attributed to a singular campaign.
Building awareness, strengthening consideration and increasing preference may not generate an attributable sale today, but they can influence whether someone chooses a brand tomorrow, next month or further into the future.
Brand-lift studies, changes in awareness, consideration and preference, as well as longer-term sales analysis, can help advertisers understand whether their investment is building future demand.
If budgets continually favour audiences and placements that deliver the quickest measurable return, investment in future demand can become harder to defend. Marketers may find themselves increasingly reliant on people already familiar with the brand, while activity that could bring new customers into consideration receives less attention.
ROAS remains an important indicator of short-term performance, while incrementality gives a clearer understanding of the additional value created by that investment. Both matter, but sustainable growth requires CMOs to understand not just the return attributed to their media but how much additional value it genuinely creates.




