‘Deteriorating Prospects’ For Media Sector

By

2 minutes

The entire media sector has been substantially downgraded by analysts at ABN Amro, following the attacks on the US on Tuesday 11 September. The broker says that the outlook for advertising has deteriorated ‘significantly’ in the two weeks since the tragedy and there will be a negative short-term effect, particularly for broadcasters. ABN is now…


The entire media sector has been substantially downgraded by analysts at ABN Amro, following the attacks on the US on Tuesday 11 September. The broker says that the outlook for advertising has deteriorated ‘significantly’ in the two weeks since the tragedy and there will be a negative short-term effect, particularly for broadcasters.

ABN is now predicting a 1.6% decline in global adspend growth for 2002, although admits that this is by no means certain. For media companies, this continuing decline in advertising represents an increase in the danger of ‘financial distress’ throughout the sector. Advertising-led companies are to be hardest hit; the professional publishers are likely to be the least affected.

It could be up to six months before the full effects of the tragic events in US are felt on the media industry. In the meantime, the markets are likely to discount the worst, creating an even greater downside, says the broker.

For broadcasters, schedules have already been affected by coverage of the terrorist attacks on New York and Washington, leading to diminished advertising revenues (see Forecasts). Add to this the fact that many advertisers are now reassessing the content and volume of their planned campaigns and the outlook for the television sector looks even bleaker and more uncertain. Campaigns are being cancelled and scaled back following the attacks.

The table and graph below show the ratio of a sector’s market evaluation (based on stock prices) as against its earnings (EBITDA). The forecasts show the media sector as a whole falling from an actual evaluation/EBITDA ratio of 17.4 times in 2000, to a predicted 9.2 times in 2002.

Sub-sector valuations 
    
 Evaluation/EBITDA (x) 
 2000A 2001F 2002F 
Advertising agencies11.08.26.0
Professional publishing12.411.58.5
Directories19.220.210.1
Consumer publishing6.26.14.6
Pay TV41.728.214.5
Broadcasting7.19.48.9
Entertainment12.78.36.3
Media Sector 17.4 13.8 9.2 
    
Source: ABN Amro estimates, 21/09/01    

The following table shows the broadcasting sector’s share price to actual earnings ratios. Following the advertising downturn these ratios are increasing and this will probably result in stock prices falling.

Broadcasting adjusted price/earnings 
     
 2000 2001 2002 2003 
Carlton Communications6.419.848.521.9
Granada16.123.421.816.6
Mediaset13.514.116.214.5
M611.713.413.312.3
Pro Sieben9.512.724.017.2
Tf116.018.719.917.2
RTL18.425.226.219.8
SMG8.916.614.711.9
Average12.618.023.116.4
Weighted average 14.7 19.1 21.6 16.8 
     
Source: ABN Amro estimates, 21/09/01     

September and October could witness double-digit advertising declines, year on year, says ABN. This would further reduce 2001 full year forecasts by around 1% point. The most recent advertising forecasts, from 13 September, are shown below.

Ad growth forecasts: ABN Amro versus Zenith 
       
 2001 Zenith 2001 ABN Difference 2002 Zenith 2002 ABN Difference 
North America-4.2n/a*n/a*0.1n/a*n/a*
France0.8-1.1-1.93.63.5-0.1
Germany-4.0-2.31.72.02.10.1
Italy3.1-1.3-4.45.23.8-1.4
Spain-1.8-6.0-4.21.83.61.8
UK-3.0-5.4-2.42.03.71.7
Europe-1.8-2.5-0.72.73.10.4
Japan1.50.0-1.50.7-0.1-0.8
7-country total-2.6-3.7-1.10.82.41.6
Total-1.6-2.2-0.61.83.21.4
*US forecasts under review       
Source: Zenith, ABN Amro estimates       


Want to get involved in the discussion?