Liz Jaques
Liz Jaques is Newsworks’ trade marketing and PR director.
The daily newspaper market is down -8.1% on January 2011, with just one title seeing a year on year increase.
i continues to see its circulation rise. The title is up 82.3% on this time last year, when it released its first ABC figure, and has overtaken the Guardian for the first time.
The Sunday market, meanwhile, is still seeing a positive trend from the closure of the News of the World, with the Sunday red-tops and the Sunday Express all posting year on year increases.
Daily Newspaper Market
Daily Titles
Jan-11
Dec-11
Jan-12
YoY Actual Change
YoY % Change
PoP Actual Change
PoP % Change
Quality
Daily Telegraph
651,184
587,040
596,180
-55,004
-8.4
9,140
1.6
Financial Times
383,067
333,771
319,757
-63,310
-16.5
-14,014
-4.2
Guardian
279,308
230,108
229,753
-49,555
-17.7
-355
-0.2
i
133,472
221,715
243,321
109,849
82.3
21,606
9.7
Independent
185,035
119,551
117,084
-67,951
-36.7
-2,467
-2.1
Times
457,250
409,060
405,113
-52,137
-11.4
-3,947
-1.0
Mid Market
Daily Express
639,875
596,415
586,707
-53,168
-8.3
-9,708
-1.6
Daily Mail
2,136,568
1,994,908
2,011,283
-125,285
-5.9
16,375
0.8
Popular
Daily Mirror
1,194,097
1,092,182
1,122,563
-71,534
-6.0
30,381
2.8
Daily Record
306,872
274,505
276,003
-30,869
-10.1
1,498
0.5
Daily Star
734,311
616,498
624,029
-110,282
-15.0
7,531
1.2
Sun
3,001,822
2,530,843
2,751,219
-250,603
-8.3
220,376
8.7
Total Daily
10,102,861
9,006,596
9,283,012
-819,849
-8.1
276,416
3.1
Quality Daily Titles
i was the only daily title to post a YoY increase in January – up 82.3% (and 9.7% PoP)
i has overtaken the Guardian for the first time with a total circulation of 243,000, compared to the Guardian‘s 230,000
The Independent has seen the biggest actual loss over the year – down by almost 68,000 copies – closely followed by the FT
Apart from i, the Telegraph was the only quality title to enjoy a PoP increase, up 1.6% on December
Mid-Market Daily Titles
Both mid-market titles posted YoY declines – the Daily Express down -8.3% and the Daily Mail -5.9%
The Daily Mail saw a small rise on December’s figure, up 0.8%
Popular Daily Titles
All of the tabloids posted PoP increases but YoY declines
The Daily Star recorded the biggest percentage drop, down -15% YoY
However, The Sun suffered the biggest actual loss, down by 251,000 copies over the year
Despite this, The Sun still remains the top-selling newspaper with a total circulation of 2.75 million
Sunday Newspaper Market
Sunday Titles
Jan-11
Dec-11
Jan-12
YoY Actual Change
YoY % Change
PoP Actual Change
PoP % Change
Quality
Independent On Sunday
152,561
128,394
124,428
-28,133
-18.4
-3,966
-3.1
Observer
314,164
266,659
264,321
-49,843
-15.9
-2,338
-0.9
Sunday Times
1,039,371
935,442
967,975
-71,396
-6.9
32,533
3.5
Sunday Telegraph
496,128
452,858
461,772
-34,356
-6.9
8,914
2.0
Mid Market
Sunday Express
550,269
626,832
607,894
57,625
10.5
-18,938
-3.0
Mail On Sunday
1,958,083
1,909,075
1,921,010
-37,073
-1.9
11,935
0.6
Popular
Daily Star Sunday
316,712
640,406
644,804
328,092
103.6
4,398
0.7
People
500,866
780,266
770,772
269,906
53.9
-9,494
-1.2
Sunday Mirror
1,092,816
1,702,008
1,753,202
660,386
60.4
51,194
3.0
Total Sunday
6,420,970
7,441,940
7,516,178
1,095,208
17.1
74,238
1.0
Quality Sunday Titles
All four Sunday qualities in our analysis posted circulation declines on January 2011
The Sunday Times recorded the biggest actual loss (down 71,000 copies), while the Independent on Sunday saw the biggest percentage drop (-18.4% YoY)
However, the Sunday Times and the Sunday Telegraph enjoyed PoP increases
The Sunday Times remains the most-read Sunday quality with a total of 968,000 copies
Sunday Mid-Market Daily Titles
The Sunday Express continued to benefit from the closure of the NotW, alongside the red-tops – up 10.5% YoY (although it is down -3.0 PoP)
Contrary to early predictions, the Mail on Sunday has not had the same luck. The title is down -1.9% YoY – although it remains the most-read Sunday title with a total circulation of 1.92 million
Popular Sunday Titles
The popular Sunday market continues to enjoy significant YoY gains – with the Daily Star Sunday up by more than 103%
The People is up 54% and the Sunday Mirror 60% on January 2011
However, the People did post a small dip on December, down -1.2%
The Sunday Mirror remains the top-selling Sunday tabloid with a total of 1.75 million copies
Comparing the Guardian with the i is hugely misleading. The Guardian is a global brand with a reach of tens of millions. Our newspaper is a quality title with a cover price of £1.20, a different audience to the i and an ABC that includes zero bulk copies. The i is a 20p tabloid with tens of thousands of bulk copies padding out its numbers. A better comparison would be with the Independent, which is consistently selling over 100K fewer copies than the Guardian each weekday, and approximately 300K fewer copies on Saturdays, despite being cheaper.
Paper Boy
•
There are many ways to compare the circulation of national newspapers. Yes the headline figure doesn’t take into account the many ways to camouflage what is really going on with sales. However, I read The Guardian spokes person’s reply to the ABC article and thought I would make a few statements for readers to consider…
Although there are many pages to the ABC report, the very first table details overall circulation per issue (as it always has). Therefore, it is only realistic that comments will be made about the relevance of this figure. GN&M are represented on the ABC Council, so they have a way to influence and change this practice should they so wish.
For most of the quality titles (other than The Independent ones) costly bulks have been stripped out. Ceasing bulks can aid profitability – or stem losses – but GN&M needs a bigger bazooka than that to stop hemorrhaging money (annual loss for the year ending March 2011 was £33 million).
Yes the total circulation figure for ‘i‘ does include 47,000 ‘bulks’. However, in its stage of development you could argue this is a legitimate sampling exercise.
The news that ‘i‘ circulates more than The Guardian for the first time is one of those headline milestones. It highlights more The Guardian‘s rapid move away from print to digital products. I predict that for one month this year The Guardian will dip under 200,000 on circulation – year on year it is down nearly 50,000 copies or 17.7%. I think we should also celebrate the innovation of ‘i‘. Yes it is 20p and an abridged version of The Independent but the newspaper market needs publishers to be creative in how they position and develop all of their products (online and offline) and how they monetise audiences.
It is interesting that The Guardian spokes person talks about Saturday circulation – this has never been audited by ABC so something the majority of us are not privy to. The fact that The Guardian sell so many copies of their Saturday edition makes you conclude that the Monday to Friday issues are already selling less than 200k. Agencies already know this and factor it in to their negotiations. However, newspapers still resist publishing Saturday or day of week figures. Again, something GN&M can alter through the ABC Council, although it could be other newspaper groups not wanting to publish more detailed data.
And the statement that The Guardian is a global brand. Yes, it has large international audiences but it is not a global brand… discuss?
•
Comparing the Guardian with the i is hugely misleading. The Guardian is a global brand with a reach of tens of millions. Our newspaper is a quality title with a cover price of £1.20, a different audience to the i and an ABC that includes zero bulk copies. The i is a 20p tabloid with tens of thousands of bulk copies padding out its numbers. A better comparison would be with the Independent, which is consistently selling over 100K fewer copies than the Guardian each weekday, and approximately 300K fewer copies on Saturdays, despite being cheaper.
•
There are many ways to compare the circulation of national newspapers. Yes the headline figure doesn’t take into account the many ways to camouflage what is really going on with sales. However, I read The Guardian spokes person’s reply to the ABC article and thought I would make a few statements for readers to consider…