A study commissioned by the European Commission (EC) has concluded that the EU’s 2022 Digital Markets Act (DMA) and Digital Services Act have thus far failed to make the online advertising market “more competitive or transparent”, either through non-compliance, poor implementation of the law or both.
Advertisers, the study found, “still lack sufficient access to ad performance and ad placement data, limiting their ability to act ethically and demonetise illegal content and disinformation”.
Referring to Google and Meta as “gatekeepers” of the online ad market, it reads: “Most […] advertisers interviewed as part of this study expressed dissatisfaction at the level of price transparency offered by gatekeepers and indicated that, in their view, the DMA had not improved the situation […] Advertisers reported persistent limitations in their ability to understand where ads are played, reducing their capacity to manage brand safety risks.”
Brand safety tools offered by platforms were found to be viewed with scepticism by surveyed advertisers, many of whom suggested the tools were “questionable” or “semi-successful”, with “inconsistent enforcement across regions” and “limited real-time control”.
It further concluded that the DMA has failed to impact the competitive position of Google and Meta, that ad fraud “continues to be widespread” and online publishers’ financial sustainability has been placed at risk by AI-powered search engines.
Publishers hit
The study was carried out by AWO, a law firm and consultancy. AWO carried out interviews with 60 stakeholders, including advertisers, publishers, agencies, adtech companies, tech platforms and non-governmental organisations, as well as a survey of 50 advertisers. It also examined regulatory reports and academic literature.
It makes no judgement on whether stakeholders are complying with the law, instead opting to advise policymakers on how to improve existing laws or consider drafting new legislation.
According to verification providers interviewed by AWO, as much as 25% of global adspend could be going to fraudsters. Applied to the EU, this would total €15bn in 2024 alone — an amount equivalent to more than three times the revenue of the market’s largest publisher, Axel Springer.
Meanwhile, data protection initiatives created by tech giants, such as Google’s Privacy Sandbox and Apple’s App Tracking Transparency Framework, have been found to negatively impact advertising effectiveness and reduce publisher revenues. “They do not adequately balance privacy and competition, with shortcomings in both areas,” the report reads.
Moreover, the study is critical of the “consent or pay” model increasingly adopted by publishers as it “exacerbates many of online advertising’s key issues”, such as decreasing user control and increasing third-party data-sharing.
The report dovetails with recent efforts by the United Nations’ Global Initiative on Information Integrity, which has likewise warned that the profits of digital platforms have come at the expense of advertisers, consumers and the planet, and that greater transparency and regulation are needed.
‘Advertisers don’t care about anything’
Advertisers interviewed for the study expressed varied perspectives on issues of competition, transparency and the funding of harmful content online, reflecting the different degrees of in-house expertise and resources.
“More sophisticated advertisers are on top of issues like ad performance and ad pricing,” one interviewee from an advertiser industry group acknowledged. A publisher interviewed was more blunt: “Publishers are in a very weak position and advertisers don’t care about anything.”
Publishers are near-universally receiving less traffic from Google, with the situation only “getting worse” throughout the year, according to Nick Botton, a senior policy associate at AWO and co-author of the report.
Whereas Botton described publishers as “uniformly unhappy”, believing the current digital ad market to be unsustainable, advertisers surveyed were broadly “split down the middle” on whether they necessarily care about competition and transparency concerns.
But he added that “less than 1%” of advertisers “have the time, resources and care to do anything about these things”.
Numerous factors contribute to this lack of apparent care. These include a talent crisis in marketing, as well as a tendency to delegate know-how and expertise to agencies and intermediaries, thus diffusing responsibility.
Advertisers, Botton told The Media Leader, also “tend to have quite close relationships with Google and Meta”, including through formal joint business programmes aimed at offering brands better access to the platforms’ staff and more granular business data.
Media agencies, Botton suggested, are also increasingly becoming “part of the adtech stack”, buying into “the way things are now” and creating an “inherent status quo bias”.
He added: “No-one’s having that honest conversation, because who stands to benefit other than advertisers and publishers?”
The study suggests that attempts at self-regulatory online advertising standards, such as via IAB Europe, “fall short when it comes to improving transparency and reducing fraud”.
Actors that “seek to abuse online advertising to commit fraud” either avoid or exploit IAB standards, it notes.
Policy recommendations
The study makes a number of recommendations for the EC to consider enacting into policy, primarily through amending the DMA and its enforcement, but also through potential “structural separation” of tech giants.
“Many of the problems in the online advertising market identified in this study are at least partially linked to vertical integration, especially in the case of Google,” the study notes.
“Structural separation could thus provide a meaningful avenue for remedying these problems, with permanent limits on certain forms of vertical integration ensuring that the associated issues do not resurface in the long term.”
In September, Google avoided a potential forced break-up, despite being ruled a monopoly in both the online search and online adtech markets by US judges in recent years. The judge, Leonie Brinkema, declined the US Department of Justice’s request to force a divestiture, opting instead to require Google change its business practices to benefit competitors.
The EC’s own investigation into Google’s market status remains ongoing. Botton told The Media Leader that he was “disappointed” the US didn’t go further with its remedies, but he understood that it is “quite daring splitting a company like this”.
He added: “One of our conclusions is that if you want the market to change, you do have to be a bit daring. Being daring means being a little disruptive and understanding that, in the long term, the benefits of a more competitive economy are huge.”
Among other policy recommendations, the AWO suggests specifying that “gatekeepers” (Google and Meta) be required to enable independent collection of ad placement data and transaction IDs by ad verification providers, and be given a stricter framework for how they must obtain users’ consent for advertising purposes.
As Botton noted, the current DMA does not specifically require platforms to provide detailed ad placement information. Simply adding such a requirement “would do a lot” to improve the market and allow advertisers to spend their money more effectively and ethically.
To tackle ad fraud and other illegal ads, the report suggests the EU could establish a taskforce to stay on top of evolving threats, while also requiring platforms and adtech intermediaries to identify and assess “any systemic risks stemming from the design or functioning” of algorithmic online ad systems.
The issue could also be passed to consumers in order to “reduce compliance burdens” and “simplify enforcement” of privacy and data protection legislation.
“If users had one place where they could set how they want all companies to use their data […] everything becomes a lot more simple,” Botton said. “If your market is based on users having no control over their personal data, you have to ask yourself if that’s valid. Should we keep doing this?”
He observed: “There are a lot of small things you could do that could have a lot of big benefits. What we’re seeing is that, by the time you have a new law, the market has changed. It does require a bit of creativity and I do think some of the things we’ve proposed are — at least in part — simpler, with clearer lines in the sand.”
However, Botton acknowledged that any regulatory scheme relies on enforcement and penalties for non-compliance that are severe enough to deter actors from breaking the law.
“There’s very little threat in the EU regulatory framework at the moment,” he concluded.





