Mars announced this week that is was to embark on an expensive, not to mention expansive rebranding, so we will no longer “Work, Rest and Play” with the chocolate bar. But while a new approach can inject fresh vigour into a brand, is there loyalty and value born of familiarity to be lost by ditching familiar slogans and characters? Denise Turner of Media Planning Group investigates.

For agencies and their advertiser clients, getting the advertising right is crucial to the success and health of the brands concerned. A lot of time and effort goes into determining the strategy and how that should be translated into an advertising campaign. And one of the key dilemmas that must be addressed on a regular basis is how to maintain continuity of brand cues whilst stimulating consumer interest. This is especially true of larger, well-established brands that have been communicating with consumers for many years.
Some recent examples of different approaches to this dilemma are Tetley, Oxo and PG Tips. Tetley has changed everything in order to follow its new strategy aimed at recruiting new tea-drinkers and hence a younger segment to the brand. It has made the Tetley Tea Folk redundant and adopted an approach with a wider appeal which focuses on everyday heroes.
Will it be successful? Oxo made similar wholesale changes just over two years ago when it dropped the Oxo family in favour of ads featuring modern households, such as a single mum and a group of lads. This was a major departure, gaining a lot of PR coverage as it had had the family at the centre of its advertising since 1955. It would appear that the move away from core brand icon and values was not as effective as had been hoped Oxo has now gone back to its roots for its latest ads but with a few changes, introducing the new updated family.
PG Tips has been famous for it chimps which have appeared in its advertising for over 40 years and this long-term strategy has been very effective for the brand. However the new multi-media campaign has sent the chimps back to the jungle and focuses on the ‘PG moment’. Initial analysis would suggest that PG Tips have followed the same route as Oxo and Tetley, moving completely away from their original advertising strategy and losing their easily-recognisable icons, the chimp family. However a closer look reveals that they have managed to retain key elements of previous advertising, such as the cute aspect and a reinforcement of the importance of the moment of drinking PG Tips.
It is always difficult to gauge the right time to change a long-running campaign and the extent to which it should be changed. Oxo flirted with moving away from its advertising heritage but came back to an updated version of the original concept. Tetley has also taken a risk in dropping recognisable brand icons and values and the jury is still out as to whether they will succeed where Oxo apparently did not. PG Tips in contrast have identified a few key elements for the brand which have been incorporated into a newer, fresher strategy. This is in essence a compromise between radical change and maintaining the status quo. The key to success in this strategy is correctly isolating brand values and adapting them for the future.
So have PG Tips found the route to success? Only time will tell.
If you would like to respond or make further comment on this or any other NewsLine article, please email [email protected]
Subscribers can access previous articles by NewsLine columnists in the Columnist Archive – click button on left.




